Thursday 25 February 2021
News ID: 86639
Publish Date: 17 January 2021 - 21:36
PARIS (Dispatches) -- Tens of thousands of protesters marched across France Saturday to denounce a security bill critics say would restrict the filming of police and posting images to social media, notably to document cases of police brutality.
Thousands marched in Paris and cities across France, many of them angry about they say was the "disproportionate” response by police when they broke up an illegal New Year’s rave in Brittany that attracted some 2,400 people.
Estimates of the turnout varied widely between the authorities and the activists: while police put the total turnout across the country at 34,000, organizers insisted it was closer to 200,000.
In Paris, the marchers came out despite a rare snowfall, carrying banners with slogans such as "Police everywhere, justice nowhere”, and "State of emergency, police state.”
"It’s a strange dictatorship, one asks how far they will go with this law,” one marcher in the northern city of Lille, who identified himself only by his first name Francois, told AFP.
"If this is the case in the country of the rights of man and freedom, then I’m ashamed to be French!” he added.
Police arrested 75 people across the country, 24 of them in Paris, said Interior Minister Gerard Darmanin, while 12 police officers and paramilitary officers were injured.
Police also intervened to break up an illegal rave near the Paris demonstration, Darmanin said in a tweet.
Footage of white police beating up an unarmed black music producer in his Paris studio on November 21 has amplified anger over the legislation, condemned by many as signaling a rightward lurch by President Emmanuel Macron.
Other recent incidents caught on camera have shown Paris police using violence to tear down a migrant camp.
The protesters are also against the use of ramped-up surveillance tools like drones and pedestrian cameras.
In the face of mounting protests, Macron’s ruling LREM party has announced it will rewrite the bill’s controversial Article 24 that deals with filming the police.
The "marches for freedom” have been called by an umbrella grouping

 that includes Amnesty International and several unions, including those gathering journalists and film directors.
The proposal, which has already been approved by the National Assembly, will be examined by the Senate, France’s upper parliamentary chamber, in March.
Protesters demand a complete withdrawal of the law. They argue that the law curbs the right of reporters to cover police brutality and contradicts "the fundamental public freedoms of our Republic.”
Under the bill, offenders could be jailed for up to a year, and fined 45,000 euros ($53,000) for sharing images of police officers.
French police brutality came to the spotlight in December last year when a video footage, circulating online, showed the violent arrest of a music producer for not wearing a face mask — required under coronavirus restrictions.
Three police officers followed the man, identified as Michel Zecler inside his music studio in Paris, and began repeatedly punching him and beating him with a truncheon. They also subjected Zecler to racial abuse.
The police were unaware they were being filmed by a surveillance camera.
Police also came under scrutiny earlier, after people posted videos on social media of officers hitting demonstrators as they cleared a refugee camp in central Paris. Both incidents provoked angry protests across the country.
President Macron — who sparked major controversies over derogatory statements against Islam and Muslims late last year — said that he had called on his government to devise plans to restore the public’s confidence in the police and to fight against all forms of discrimination.

* Comment: